Wednesday, February 08, 2006

On religion

Today, during a very boring lecture, a friend gave me his take on religion. Here it is, in my words.

When people were still hunting and lived in caves, they were shit scared of nature and there was nothing they could do - to control it or predict it. They didn't know what caused storms, earthquakes, and stuff and that scared them shitless. So they started praying, for lack of anything better to do. They prayed to the sun, the rain, the wind, the moon and the larger animals. That is how religion must have evolved. So basically religion was created out of fear of death and destruction by forces greater than people. So when and why did this concept of religion as "peaceful" and God as "kind" come about? And now that we know what caused natural disasters and we don't fear any animal anymore, atleast not to the point of thinking we'll be a snack soon, so why do we still have religion? What do we fear so much now that we need something bigger than us to protect us?


He didn't say it so well, the words are all mine, but that is what he meant.

What do you think?

Justification of life? Purpose of life? Meaning of life? Faith? Social conditioning? "You are what your childhood makes"? Guilt? Fear?

I am not debating the existence of God. Just the need for religion.

Did you see the news reports on the caricatures? Go here, here or here.

I don't know what to think. A part of me thinks, "What the hell were they thiking? They know people are very sensitive about religion. They are either stupid or suicidal." Another part of me thinks, "Take a joke. Yeah, a bad joke but seriously!." Death threats over cartoons? CLosing embassies? Buring the American flag when it was Denmark, Germany, France, Spain and Italy which carried the cartoons? Boycott of products?

Isn't it time for people to grow up?

Would I feel this offended if Krishna was made fun of? No. I'd probably laugh along. But yeah, I can see the BJP and the RSS and the VHP going up in arms the way they did for M.F.Hussein's Saraswati and the movie Fire. Can Christians take a joke about Jesus Christ? I didn't know, so I googled "Jesus Jokes" and this was the first link. What about Buddhists? They are the best of us all! There is actually a category called Buddhist Humor and nobody has gotten killed yet.

What do you think? I think it is ok to make fun of religions. Maybe humor is the first step toward acceptance? Maybe not but by killing the people who poke fun at you, what do you prove? That you are an over-sensitve buffoon who can't take a joke? Is it worth it?

Why are people who are so into religion so obsessed with it? What is it about religion that surgically removes some people's 'rational' bits? Do they think God does not have a sense of humor? Is that not insulting to God?

9 comments:

  1. Meer you have to read this..very informative
    http://observer.guardian.co.uk/focus/story/0,,1702538,00.html

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey the continuation of the link is below
    ....1702538,00.html

    ReplyDelete
  3. I guess its because of this insecurity, a need to belong somewhere, a group - anything! To explain things, we wudnt like to find about or are too busy to enquire about - easy explanation is to leave it to god !

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hey meera, the theory ur friend proposes is an intersting one and also in a way plausible one too. But once u realize that religion was nothing higher but born out of fear, can u really believe in it or is there a need to believe in it?

    @ Shriyukta -- isnt, leaving the things we don understand to God faking of reality? I would rather live in ignorance and hope to know about the things I don understand in future rather than shying away and say they are not in my realm of understanding and leave it to a superior authority called God.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Not fair.

    I come back from a trip, with three things to blog about.

    Religion -- mainly because of the cartoon thingie.

    Turning 23.

    Writer's block.

    And then I visit your blog ...

    Not fair at all...

    ReplyDelete
  6. musafir - life....

    shriyukta & Catch 22- i think it makes things easier to handle if you can just dump all of it on god.

    ReplyDelete
  7. >What do we fear so much now that we need something bigger than us to protect us?<

    cancer. aids. the guy wearing saffron. the guy carrying the green flag. george w. submachine guns. bureaucrats. suicide bombers. the opposite sex. money. sunlight. dark. insects. mad dogs. pollution. cold. heat. the woman in the next room. the guy sitting next to you. aimlessness. yourself. life.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree with you but only upto a certain point. My view is that when those caricatures were published, the newspapers must have had a fairly good idea about the backlash and it was probably the reason that they were published in the first place. So they cannot be let off under the garb of freedom of expression. Religion is more than a father or mother to millions of people around the globe. Now I can understand if someone abuses my mother by mistake but if it is done on purpose I'll definitely give that person atleast a black eye.

    ReplyDelete